The Old Fashioned Is the Most Versatile Cocktail You Own. Here Are 4 Versions to Prove It.
Most people make one Old Fashioned. They find a ratio that works, they use the same whiskey every time, and they call it their signature drink. Nothing wrong with that.
But the Old Fashioned structure — spirit, sweetener, bitters, ice, citrus peel — is the most adaptable framework in the cocktail world. It works with bourbon, rye, mezcal, fat-washed spirits, cold brew, and everything in between. Most people are sitting on three or four versions they haven't tried yet.
I'm Shane McKnight. I develop cocktail recipes at Top Hat Provisions and I'll be upfront: I'm biased toward our Old Fashioned Syrup. But the reason I built a syrup around this drink is because I've watched it travel across every spirit category and come back equally compelling every time. The builds below are the ones worth making. Every one has a zero-proof option. All four use the same ¼ oz of syrup as the through-line.
WhiskeyMezcalFat-WashedStirredZero Proof
The short version: The Old Fashioned is the most versatile cocktail you own. Here are four builds — Classic, Cold Brew, Oaxacan Mezcal, and Bacon Fat-Washed — that show exactly how far the structure stretches. Every one uses Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup as the sweetener. Every one includes a zero-proof option.
Why the Old Fashioned works with almost any spirit
The Old Fashioned is three things: a spirit, something to soften it, and something to frame it. The spirit is the point. Everything else gets out of the way.
The structure
Sweetener adds body and rounds the edges. Bitters add complexity and make the spirit smell like something worth sipping. The citrus peel oils land on top and lift it. That's the whole framework — and it's flexible enough to accommodate almost any aged spirit.
What breaks it
Over-sweetening, under-dilution, or bad ice. Get those three things right and the spirit carries the drink. Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup pre-balances the bitters, citrus, and spice in one pour — so you're not managing four separate bottles while the ice melts.
4 Old Fashioned variations worth making
Start with the Classic. Make the Cold Fashioned the night after. Give yourself a weekend for the Bacon.
1. The Classic Old Fashioned
Bourbon · Stirred · Spirit-Forward · 3 min
2 oz bourbon (best you have), ¼ oz Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup, garnish: expressed orange peel. Rocks glass, large cube.
Two ingredients. One rule: use the best whiskey you have. The syrup's job is to get out of the way and let the bourbon speak. Stir 8–10 seconds over the cube. Express orange peel over the top.
Zero proof: Any zero-proof whiskey alternative. The build stays identical.
Cold Brew Bourbon · Stirred · Coffee-Forward · 3 min
2 oz bourbon, ¼ oz Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup, ½ oz cold brew coffee concentrate, optional: expressed orange peel. Mixing glass → strain over large cube.
Same structure, with cold brew concentrate adding roasted backbone and silky coffee lift. Not dessert — the bourbon stays center stage. Stir 15–20 seconds. The cold brew reads as depth, not sweetness.
Zero proof: Swap bourbon for a zero-proof spirit alternative. Keep the cold brew — it carries the build.
2 oz barrel-aged mezcal, ¼ oz Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup, 2 dashes Fee Bros Aztec Chocolate Bitters, 3 drops 5% saline solution, expressed orange peel + optional smoking cinnamon stick.
Barrel-aged mezcal brings oak, earth, and smoke where bourbon brings warmth and vanilla. Three drops of 5% saline (5g salt in 95g water) suppresses bitterness and pulls the smoke forward — it's a bartender technique, not a flavor addition. The result is bold, contemplative, and completely different from anything else on this list.
Zero proof: Monday Zero Alcohol Mezcal or Monday Zero Alcohol Añejo Tequila. Everything else stays identical.
2 oz bacon fat-washed bourbon (full recipe at link), ¼ oz Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup, garnish: candied bacon strip.
You do 10 minutes of active work, put a bowl in the freezer overnight, and wake up with a bottle of fat-washed bourbon that tastes like a campfire, a diner, and a cocktail bar decided to collaborate. The bacon fat rounds the sharp edges and adds savory richness that doesn't read as "bacon" — it reads as "something extraordinary is happening in this glass." Make this for a dinner party. It becomes the most talked-about thing you've ever poured.
Zero proof: Any zero-proof bourbon or whiskey alternative. No fat wash needed — the candied bacon garnish carries the concept.
Every build above uses one thing in common: ¼ oz of Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup. It replaces four separate bottles — simple syrup, Angostura bitters, orange bitters, and spice — with one consistent pour. The ratio stays the same across every variation. The spirit changes, the supporting cast doesn't. That consistency is the whole point.
⭐ Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup — 8oz
Bitters + citrus + spice + sweetness in one pour. Replaces 4 ingredients. Works for Classic, Cold Fashioned, Oaxacan, Bacon — and any other whiskey build where you want bitters, citrus, and sweetness together.
Four Old Fashioned variations — all built with Top Hat Old Fashioned Syrup.
Cart
0 items
Your Cart is Empty
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
One or more of the items in your cart is a deferred, subscription, or recurring purchase. By continuing, I agree to the cancellation policy and authorize you to charge my payment method at the prices, frequency and dates listed on this page until my order is fulfilled or I cancel, if permitted.
